Voting experts urge Ninth Circuit to reject DOJ lawsuit over Alaska Senate race
Amicus briefs filed by a former Maricopa County recorder and UCLA election scholars ask the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals to dismiss the Justice Department's suit seeking to block certification of Alaska's Senate election.
Former Maricopa County Recorder Stephen Richer and scholars from the University of California, Los Angeles School of Law’s Safeguarding Democracy Project submitted amicus briefs on Friday urging the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals to reject the Justice Department’s lawsuit that aims to prevent Alaska from certifying its U.S. Senate results if incumbent Republican Dan Sullivan loses.
The lawsuit, filed by the Trump administration, argues that a long-shot candidate named Dan J. Sullivan could confuse voters because of the similarity to the incumbent’s name. The briefs contend that state election officials have already addressed the issue, distinguishing the two candidates on the ballot and using Alaska’s ranked-choice voting system to reduce any potential confusion.
“Leading election law experts from across the political spectrum uniformly derided this lawsuit filed by the United States,” the Safeguarding Democracy Project brief reads, adding that the court should send a clear message that Alaska has the authority to certify its own election results.
Richer’s brief emphasizes that Alaska’s courts ruled the namesake could remain on the ballot and that the state’s election machinery functioned as designed. “There is no basis for the federal government to challenge that result—or for a federal court to circumvent it,” the brief states.
The briefs also invoke the major-questions doctrine, arguing that the Justice Department lacks clear congressional authorization for such a significant intervention, and cite the laches doctrine, noting that the suit was filed late in the election cycle, which could undermine voter confidence and the administration of elections.
A district court dismissed the Justice Department’s suit on Nov. 1, and the department has not yet filed a brief outlining its legal arguments. The Senate race remains unresolved, with Democratic candidate Mary Peltola currently leading incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan in the vote count.