Analyst predicts Prime Minister Andy Burnham will defer difficult welfare and EU decisions
Left

Analyst predicts Prime Minister Andy Burnham will sidestep hard welfare and EU choices

Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.

Summary

Columnist John Rentoul argues that Prime Minister Andy Burnham is likely to push aside contentious welfare reforms and EU policy decisions while keeping Labour’s factions onside with cautious, incrementalism dressed up as pragmatism.

Columnist John Rentoul writes that Prime Minister Andy Burnham appears to be avoiding the kind of difficult policy choices that have dogged previous leaders. He notes that Burnham was warned that the early release of prisoners convicted of killing PC Andrew Harper would be controversial, yet the government later found a way to exclude them. Rentoul also points out that Burnham faced pressure to raise taxes in the Budget but delivered only a modest increase for banks, which he described as the "most popular Budget for a number of years."

Rentoul says the upcoming welfare plan, to be announced by Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden, will test Burnham's ability to restrain benefit spending growth while keeping Labour MPs from breaking ranks. He observes that several former rebels, including Louise Haigh, Lucy Powell and Angela Rayner, now hold senior cabinet positions, which may help contain internal party tensions and preserve the leadership's fragile balance.

Citing a Financial Times column by Janan Ganesh, Rentoul reports that Burnham is portrayed as a "master at work" who uses left-leaning language to appeal to progressive voters without committing to substantial policy changes. Ganesh describes Burnham as a "visionary tinkerer" and a "national mood-manager," labels that suggest political calibration more than any serious willingness to confront structural problems.

Rentoul extends the analysis to Europe, noting that Burnham has raised the prospect of rejoining the EU without committing to concrete negotiations, a strategy he compares to former Prime Minister Harold Wilson's handling of party and public opinion. He concludes that while Burnham may continue to defer difficult decisions, the durability of this approach remains uncertain.

Keep reading — for free

Create a free account to follow the news. No card required.