Navi Pillay Reaffirms UN Report Finding Israel Committed Genocide in Gaza

Summary

Nobel laureate Navi Pillay reiterated the UN Commission of Inquiry's conclusion that Israel's actions in Gaza constitute genocide, citing systematic killings, widespread destruction and intent to destroy the Palestinian population.

Nobel Peace Prize laureate and former UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay said the UN Commission of Inquiry's September 2025 report that found Israel had committed genocide in Gaza remains solid. In an interview with Haaretz at her home in Durban, Pillay said the commission based its conclusion on a systematic pattern of Israeli actions, including the killing of roughly 75,000 Palestinians, the destruction of most homes and critical infrastructure, and the dismantling of essential services such as hospitals, schools, agricultural land and fishing facilities.

"It's not a defence to genocide to say, 'Yeah, but I didn't kill all of them,'" Pillay said, adding that the Genocide Convention covers the destruction of a protected group in whole or in part and that failure to prevent genocide is also a crime.

She noted that statements by senior Israeli officials, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, then-Defence Minister Yoav Gallant and President Isaac Herzog, were assessed alongside the broader conduct to infer genocidal intent. The commission recommended prosecution for incitement to genocide for all three.

Pillay highlighted the use of aerial bombing and other weapons designed to kill large numbers of people, describing them as indiscriminate. She questioned Israel's restrictions on essential medicines and attacks on civilians, ambulance workers and journalists, and cited video footage showing alleged abuse of detainees.

The report also condemned the destruction of Gaza's only fertility clinic, which stored up to 5,000 embryos, as an act intended to prevent births among Palestinians. Pillay criticized Israel for denying the commission access to Gaza and called for international media to be allowed entry.

Beyond Gaza, the commission has examined Israel's conduct in the occupied Palestinian territories and previously recommended that the UN General Assembly seek an advisory opinion from the International Court of Justice. The ICJ in 2024 ruled that Israel's continued presence in the occupied territory was unlawful.

Pillay stressed that states must act on International Criminal Court arrest warrants, acknowledging that justice can be a slow process. She said the ICJ is expected to deliver a ruling in South Africa's genocide case against Israel in the coming years.

According to the Palestinian Ministry of Health, at least 74,645 Palestinians have been killed and 175,978 injured since October 7, 2023.

Source

Maktoob

Keep reading — for free

Create a free account to follow the news. No card required.