JK Rowling reposts warning that draft Conversion Practices bill is a new assault on gay rights
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
JK Rowling shared a post on X saying the draft Conversion Practices bill could be the biggest threat to gay rights since Section 28, echoing Kevin McKenna’s criticism of a measure opponents say would criminalise ordinary speech.
JK Rowling reposted a message on X that described the draft Conversion Practices bill as "the biggest threat to gay rights since Section 28". The post quoted columnist Kevin McKenna, who warned that the legislation could let the state intrude on parental decisions about children’s gender and sexual orientation.
"The proposed Conversion Practices bill risks an authoritarian government usurping the role of parents in their children’s lives," McKenna wrote.
In an article for The Herald, McKenna argued that, if enacted, the bill would represent the most significant challenge to gay rights since the 1988 Section 28 law. He said the bill’s sweeping wording could perversely reinforce the very conversion practices it claims to ban, especially by nudging vulnerable young people toward identifying as transgender or non-binary.
The draft legislation proposes three offences aimed at criminalising conversion practices. It defines such practices as conduct intended to influence an individual’s sexual orientation or gender identity, including non-binary identity. The bill exempts actions carried out in the course of health-care services unless they exceed what is reasonably expected of a professional. It also addresses conduct facilitated abroad by a person located in the UK.
Critics, including the LGB Alliance, argue that the bill could expose parents or others who suggest a young person might be gay rather than trans to criminal prosecution, potentially carrying up to five years in prison. They claim the legislation could be used for “malicious prosecutions” in custody disputes and other personal grievances. Some opponents also contend that including trans identity may negatively affect youths merely exploring their sexual orientation.
The government has responded that the bill is not intended to limit open or exploratory conversations about sexual orientation or gender by parents, teachers, counsellors or health professionals.