UK Court Ruling Pushes Chagos Islands Fight Back Into the Legal Maze
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
A British Indian Ocean Territories Court of Appeal panel overturned a lower-court victory for Chagossians, ruling that the right-of-abode question must be decided by the English Court of Appeal, prolonging uncertainty over the UK government’s stalled handover plan for Mauritius.
A British Indian Ocean Territories (BIOT) Court of Appeal panel has overturned a lower-court ruling that granted Chagossians a right of abode on the islands, declaring that the matter must instead be decided by the English Court of Appeal. The judges – Sir Howard Morrison, Mr Justice Lane, Mrs Justice Nott, Mrs Justice Plimmer and Mr Justice Bird – said the BIOT court had no jurisdiction to make that determination, underscoring once again how colonial-era legal structures still control the fate of the islanders.
The decision leaves a group of Chagossians who re-occupied one of the islands in protest at the UK government’s proposed handover to Mauritius facing an uncertain future, while the wider legal battle is set to drag on in London next year. For those directly affected, the ruling prolongs a struggle that has already stretched across generations and continues to be managed through distant courts rather than through a just resolution.
The dispute stems from Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer’s 2024 agreement to transfer the Chagos archipelago to Mauritius and lease back the Diego Garcia airbase for £30 billion. That plan has since stalled after US President Donald Trump withdrew his support, leaving the government’s much-touted arrangement in limbo and exposing the fragility of the deal.
Lawyers for the islanders have appealed to the English Court of Appeal and also filed an application with the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, which is due to meet in Bermuda in April. The legal campaign continues as the islanders try to force a meaningful hearing in a process that has repeatedly delayed substantive justice.
"The judges at the BIOT appeal court made a ‘howling error’," a representative of the islanders said, adding that the bill for Diego Garcia had not received Royal assent and would need to be reintroduced.
"We fight on," said James Tumbridge, the islanders’ lawyer, noting that the appeal’s success meant the government had won on jurisdictional grounds and that the case would likely proceed to the Privy Council.
Defence Secretary Wes Streeting emphasized that any settlement would require US consent, given the shared use of the Diego Garcia base. The UK government has not said whether it will still pursue the Chagos deal despite the repeated legislative and legal setbacks, leaving the islanders trapped in yet another round of bureaucratic uncertainty.
The judgment also highlighted the unique constitutional status of the BIOT, which, unlike most British Overseas Territories, is governed solely by the Royal Prerogative, giving the Crown broad authority over its legislative, executive and judicial arrangements. That arrangement remains a stark reminder of how exceptional powers continue to shape the islands’ future without the consent of those who live there.