Victoria's infrastructure authority blasted for redacted documents in construction inquiry
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
The Victorian Infrastructure Delivery Authority drew sharp criticism from a royal commission after delaying key material and heavily redacting records tied to the Gap Road level-crossing project, obscuring issues in a public-interest investigation into the state’s construction industry.
Counsel assisting the commissioner, Chris Young, KC, warned the Victorian Infrastructure Delivery Authority (VIDA) on Thursday that its submission of “plainly redacted material” without explanation was obstructing the royal commission’s investigation into the state’s construction industry. Commissioner Chris Kourakis, AC, said the late provision of information had disrupted the orderly conduct of the inquiry.
Young pointed out that the unredacted material later exposed concerns that further work stoppages at the Gap Road level-crossing removal site could force an extension of the project deadline. He also drew attention to a redacted note indicating the CFMEU was “driving some companies re. Aboriginal employment out of business.”
Two versions of handwritten notes by former Rail Projects Victoria chief executive Evan Tattersall were tabled. One version, submitted on November 7, was almost entirely blacked out, while the unredacted notebook released later showed a note about a potential weekend work extension.
The authority also disclosed text messages concerning Gap Road that referenced the Premier’s private office. The messages involved former adviser Matthew Toner and Matthew Phelan, who later became chief of staff to Premier Jacinta Allan.
"We have repeatedly pointed out, commissioner, this commission has but a short time to complete its work. It has compulsory powers, and those powers are reinforced by sanctions, which do ultimately include imprisonment," Young said.
VIDA’s counsel apologized, saying the delay was unintentional. Premier Ben Carroll acknowledged the government’s performance had fallen short and pledged to support the commission, though he declined further comment.
The hearings also examined the June 2022 work stoppage at Gap Road, where the Construction, Forestry and Maritime Employees Union (CFMEU) shut down the project to challenge the Australian Workers’ Union’s involvement. Contractors John Holland and CPB Contractors testified that the industrial relations climate had become increasingly combative, blaming the escalation on a turf war between the CFMEU and the AWU.
"Demarcation has got a little blurry ... You’ve got one union trying to step into another union’s patch of work," CPB managing director Craig Nuttall said.
The commission’s inquiry continues.