Mississippi voter-roll mess exposes the risks of relying on bad commercial data
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
Experian data led to the mistaken inactivation of more than 230,000 Mississippi voters, but election officials and state law already provided safeguards that critics now want ignored in the rush to politicize the episode.
A contract signed by Secretary of State Michael Watson in 2024 to obtain unverified address data from Experian was used by county election officials to flag and inactivate voters who were actually still eligible. By Election Day, more than 230,000 Mississippi voters had been mistakenly listed as inactive, creating confusion and delays at polling places and exposing the dangers of depending on questionable outside data.
A coalition of civil-rights organizations, including the NAACP Legal Defense Fund, the ACLU of Mississippi and the Southern Poverty Law Center, sent Watson and senior elections attorney Laura Henderson-Courtney a letter four days before the midterms urging the reinstatement of any voters inactivated on the basis of Experian data. The groups argued that the voters had complied with all legal requirements and that restoring them would not compromise roll integrity, though election administrators still had to balance that request against the rules already in place.
Watson’s office did not respond to the demands. Assistant Secretary of State Liz Jonson acknowledged receipt of the letter and noted that state law places the voter-roll maintenance system in a blackout period, preventing systemic updates before the election and preserving the stability of the process during voting.
On Election Day, several voters discovered their names missing from poll books. Election Commissioner Jamie Gunnells posted on Facebook about a "major disruption" caused by the "Experian fiasco," describing how the address list supplied by the secretary of state had rendered many voters inactive. In response, Watson told Gunnells that election commissioners are responsible for verifying any data they receive before acting on it, emphasizing local responsibility rather than central blame.
Individual voters recounted similar experiences. Thomas Minor and Heather Williams reported being flagged as having moved to distant addresses, while Kailyn Lott discovered her registration listed an old credit-card address, leading to her being marked inactive at the polling place. Lott eventually cast an affidavit ballot after presenting her ID, but she said the incident could discourage others from voting and underscored how badly inaccurate data can complicate an election.
State law bars inactivation or purging of voters within 90 days of a federal election, but it does not restrict the restoration of voters to active status. Critics say the reliance on commercial data, which the Experian contract explicitly disclaimed as guaranteed for accuracy, exposed systemic weaknesses in Mississippi’s voter-roll maintenance and demonstrated why official election records should not be treated as infallible.
Following the midterms, the secretary of state’s office announced it had ended its partnership with Experian and switched to a different data vendor, IDI Data. Civil-rights groups remain skeptical that the change will prevent future errors and have asked Watson to halt any pending purges of voters inactivated based on the Experian lists.
The controversy comes as Mississippi’s U.S. Senate race remains tightly contested, with Democratic candidate Scott Colom holding a narrow lead over incumbent Republican Cindy Hyde-Smith. Election officials continue to process thousands of affidavit ballots while the state reviews its voter-roll procedures and works to prevent a repeat of the error.