Seattle school board moves to fight trans-exclusionary sports initiative in court
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
The Seattle Public Schools board voted to authorize district lawyers to challenge Initiative IL-638, saying the measure threatens student privacy, clashes with existing law and could drive up costs.
The Seattle Public Schools board approved a resolution at a special meeting on Monday that allows the district to retain legal counsel and consider filing a lawsuit over Washington’s Initiative IL-638. The board, which voted against the initiative in September, said the measure would apply only to girls’ sports and could impose invasive privacy checks on female students that are not required for boys.
Board President Gina Topp said the district must “uphold the law and protect the students and families we serve” and that “when a new law raises serious questions about how it interacts with existing laws and constitutional protections, we have a responsibility to seek clarity from the courts.”
Board member Joe Mizrahi warned that the initiative could conflict with state statutes that protect student privacy and guarantee equal access to educational opportunities, adding that “we don’t see a way to implement Initiative 638 without violating those vital protections.”
Supporters of the initiative argue it is about fairness in competition. Amy Sousa, an advocate for the measure, said it “should never have come to a situation where any males were allowed to participate in the female category.”
Opponents contend that the required sex-verification procedures would undermine student dignity and intensify discrimination. Simon Thornton of Seattle expressed concern that “how they choose to enforce it… could be a really difficult situation.”
The board did not specify the type of legal action it may pursue, noting that the decision will be left to the district’s attorneys. Initiative IL-638 is set to take effect on Dec. 3, and the board suggested that other districts might follow its lead. Washington voters approved the initiative in November with 55.83% voting yes.