Former chief prosecutor warns trans conversion-therapy bill risks trampling the rule of law
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
Lord Macdonald, a former director of public prosecutions, says the draft Conversion Practices Bill is so vague that it could drag ordinary conversations between parents, clinicians and children into the criminal law.
Lord Macdonald, who led the Crown Prosecution Service from 2003 to 2008 and sits as a cross-bench peer, told The Telegraph that the draft Conversion Practices Bill is "contrary to the rule of law" because its wording does not allow people to know whether an honest conversation could constitute a criminal offence punishable by up to five years in prison. He said the minister could not identify any conduct that is currently lawful but would become unlawful under the bill, calling this a "serious problem" with the legislation.
The government published the draft bill in June, proposing five-year jail terms for anyone who uses physical or psychological abuse to prevent children from expressing a gay or transgender identity. Critics, including legal and medical professionals, argue that the bill’s references to "psychological or emotional pressure" are vague and could sweep up doctors, teachers and parents talking with children about gender issues, turning ordinary care into a possible crime.
The Church of England has expressed concern that the bill might unintentionally criminalise providing appropriate prayer, and at least a dozen Labour MPs have signalled dissatisfaction to party whips. Lord Macdonald also suggested that the legislation appears to be driven by a trans-rights lobby seeking to achieve policy goals through the bill, describing it as a "Trojan Horse".
Dr. David Bell, a former Tavistock clinician, echoed similar worries, saying the bill seems to be pushed by the same lobby that previously advocated for self-identification policies. The draft follows recent changes such as the closure of the Tavistock gender identity clinic, a ban on puberty blockers for children and new guidance that discourages immediate affirmation of a child’s transgender identity.