NFL Handbook Gives Commissioner Discretion Over Reserve/Left Squad Reinstatements, Aiyuk Case Highlights Ambiguities
Just the facts

NFL Handbook Gives Commissioner Discretion Over Reserve/Left Squad Reinstatements, Aiyuk Case Highlights Ambiguities

Summary

The NFL’s Player Personnel Handbook grants the commissioner broad authority to approve reinstatement from the reserve/left squad list, a point underscored by the ongoing dispute over wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk’s return to the 49ers.

The NFL’s Player Personnel Handbook outlines that a player placed on the reserve/left squad list must apply to the commissioner for reinstatement and cannot return in the same season. The handbook further states that a player applying in a later season is barred from reinstatement during the final 30 days of the regular season, the postseason, and the period between the trading deadline and that 30-day deadline unless the club initiates the request and the commissioner approves it.

Because the collective bargaining agreement does not address the reserve/left squad process, the league’s “management rights” clause may allow the commissioner unrestricted discretion over such applications. Since October 27, the commissioner has not approved Brandon Aiyuk’s reinstatement request, while the San Francisco 49ers have indicated they expect Aiyuk to repay up to $13 million in previously paid bonus money before the league acts.

The NFL Players Association has not commented publicly, and the lack of CBA provisions could limit its ability to intervene. Analysts note that past reinstatement cases could inform whether the league’s current handling sets a precedent.

Legal experts suggest that separating the financial dispute from the reinstatement decision may be necessary, but for now the commissioner’s approval remains tied to the 49ers’ conditions.

Keep reading — for free

Create a free account to follow the news. No card required.