Church of England warns draft conversion-practice bill could criminalise prayer
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
The Church of England and Catholic leaders say the proposed Conversion Practices Bill risks sweeping up prayer, pastoral care and ordinary family conversations, and they are pressing lawmakers to narrow it before it becomes law.
The Church of England said the draft Conversion Practices Bill should be amended so it does not end up criminalising prayer and pastoral support under the guise of protecting people from abuse. In a statement to The Telegraph, a church spokesperson said legislation must leave room for discussion and disagreement while genuinely targeting coercive conversion practices rather than ordinary religious counsel.
The draft bill, which would make it an offence to attempt to change a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity, carries a maximum sentence of five years in prison. Critics argue the wording is so broad that it could also expose parents, therapists and religious leaders to prosecution simply for offering prayer or advice.
"We believe that everyone is made in the image of God and should be cherished for who they are," the spokesperson said, adding that the church would reflect its concerns during the pre-legislative scrutiny process.
Roman Catholic leaders echoed those concerns. Archbishop John Sherrington of Liverpool said the bishops recognise the need to protect people from abuse, but argued that existing laws already cover coercive practices. He warned that the bill could create uncertainty around lawful pastoral care and family life, and urged politicians to abandon the legislation rather than rush ahead with a law that may do more harm than good.
Bishop Brian McGee of the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of Scotland described the proposal as overreaching into "normal daily family life, pastoral conversations and everyday teaching," reinforcing fears that the draft is cast far too widely.
The government defended the draft, saying it targets a specific form of abuse while preserving freedom of expression for religious leaders. A government spokesperson said the bill has been welcomed by some religious groups and that "freedom of belief, whether faith-based or wider, will be respected."
Opponents, including the Christian Institute and the Ban Conversion Practices Coalition, say the bill could criminalise legitimate speech and prayer, and warn that it may even lead to police investigations of private family conversations.