Justice Department Retreats From Lawsuit Over 20,000 California Ballots After Supreme Court Rebuff
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
After the Supreme Court refused to take up the appeal, the U.S. Justice Department moved to drop its case seeking to set aside 20,000 California ballots, ending a bid that critics saw as an alarming attempt to cast doubt on lawful voting.
The Justice Department filed a motion on Friday to voluntarily dismiss its lawsuit that had asked a federal court to require California and Los Angeles County election officials to separate about 20,000 ballots it claimed might belong to non-citizen voters. The request became moot after the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear the administration’s appeal of lower-court rulings that rejected the relief, closing the door on a case that had raised serious concerns about voter suppression and overreach.
U.S. District Judge David O. Carter had earlier ruled that the government’s request likely violated constitutional principles that give states and Congress authority over elections, and could conflict with federal statutes that limit broad voter-roll vetting close to an election. He also scheduled further fact-finding, including the appointment of a special master to review the data supporting the government’s claim, underscoring how thin and contested the evidence appeared to be.
"In light of the Supreme Court’s denial, the United States is evaluating how to best ensure that American votes are protected, including by preventing vote dilution by noncitizens. By the time of the Court’s hearing on Nov. 13, California will have already commingled the challenged ballots with lawful ones, making segregation impossible," Assistant U.S. Attorney Julie Hamill wrote in the filing.
Hamill added that the administration had exhausted its appeals and could no longer obtain the relief it sought, making dismissal necessary. Justice Department spokesperson Kiersten Pels described the litigation as "moot" but said the administration continues to pursue measures to remove non-citizens from voter rolls in California, a campaign that civil-rights advocates have long warned can sweep up eligible voters.
Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk Dean Logan, a defendant, said he was pleased that the administration had accepted the court’s findings and that state and federal law set clear standards for verifying voter eligibility. California Attorney General Rob Bonta said the administration had given up its effort after losing in every court, including the Supreme Court, and reaffirmed the state’s commitment to protect voting rights.
The case had drawn attention to the reliability of a list the Justice Department used to flag voters, with local officials reporting that many flagged individuals appeared to be U.S.-born. The litigation’s dismissal ends the pending hearing scheduled for Nov. 13, which would have examined the methodology behind the list and allowed expert testimony, leaving unanswered questions about how such a sweeping and potentially flawed list was assembled.