Victorian Premier Ben Carroll faces backlash as Labor’s support collapses under a cost-of-living crisis
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
Labor’s primary vote in Victoria has plunged 12 points and Premier Ben Carroll’s personal approval is at minus 11, exposing how deeply the party has alienated voters and how uncertain its prospects are in Niddrie and across the state ahead of the election.
A new Resolve Political Monitor for The Age shows Labor’s primary vote in Victoria falling to 25 per cent, a 12-point decline from the 2022 election, while Premier Ben Carroll’s personal approval rating has slipped to minus 11. The data underline the extent to which Carroll and Labor have lost public trust, and the difficulty he faces in retaining his seat in Niddrie while trying to prevent a statewide defeat.
Carroll has held the Niddrie seat, a traditionally Labor electorate, since a 2012 by-election. He currently leads by 6.7 points, but senior Labor figures, speaking anonymously, say the seat could serve as a bellwether for the party’s overall performance. If Carroll retains Niddrie, Labor may limit losses; if he is defeated, the scale of the rejection could be broader.
“I intend to stay in parliament. I am not counting on not winning,” Carroll said.
“I do believe this is the most consequential election for Victoria, and I am going to do everything possible to fight for working people,” he added.
Carroll, 51, grew up in the western suburbs of Melbourne and entered politics after working in retail, insurance and as a legal adviser. Colleagues describe him as diligent and reliable, though not a particularly charismatic public figure. He emphasizes consensus-building and has warned that the rise of populist parties such as One Nation could affect the election outcome, a sign of the broader political discontent Labor has failed to address.
“One Nation is going to win seats, both in the lower and upper house,” Carroll said.
He also noted that Labor has lost some support among the business community and is adjusting policies on remote work, land tax and integrity agencies to regain trust, after years of policies that critics say have alienated both workers and employers.
“I have shown integrity. It’s not just about words, it’s about deeds,” Carroll said.
Carroll says a future government would focus on fiscal discipline, renewable energy, critical-minerals processing and advanced manufacturing, aiming to position Victoria as a leading economic hub, though voters may judge these promises against Labor’s record and worsening poll numbers.
Within Labor, there remains internal disagreement over the leadership transition that brought Carroll to the premiership. Some members recall his 2023 leadership bid as contentious, while others view his current position as a realistic response to shifting party dynamics. Factional rivals are reportedly discussing succession plans should Labor lose the election, underscoring a party more preoccupied with internal manoeuvring than with rebuilding public confidence.
Despite the challenges, Carroll continues a door-to-door campaign in his electorate, seeking to maintain voter support amid a volatile political environment and mounting frustration with Labor’s direction.