Australian government defends sweeping teen social-media ban as Reddit fights back in court
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
The Australian government insisted its under-16 social-media ban only lightly touches political communication, while Reddit challenged what it says is an overbroad, rushed restriction in the High Court.
The Australian government brushed aside Reddit's High Court argument that the ban on under-16 accounts across major social-media platforms unfairly curbs political communication for teenagers. The government insisted that the legislation creates only a modest, indirect limitation, even as critics see a heavy-handed intervention into young people’s access to online discourse.
Reddit, which ranks among the world’s most visited websites, argued that the legislation was rushed in 2024 and was overly broad, prompting the communications minister to introduce additional rules in 2026 to address design features deemed harmful to minors.
In court, government barrister Stephen Lloyd SC said the law was intended from the start to allow rule-making by the minister and should be assessed based on its current operation. He explained that the ban targets features such as endless scrolling, likes, personalized recommendations and push notifications, which are associated with risks like sleep disruption, depression, anxiety and suicidal thoughts among users under 16.
Lloyd emphasized that the measure is not a blanket restriction but is aimed at minimizing adverse effects of those features. He noted that while Reddit permits reading content without an account, personalization tools are limited to account holders, and any “Reddit Kids” version would still need age verification.
Since the ban took effect in December of the previous year, more than five million accounts identified as belonging to users under 16 have been suspended or deactivated across ten platforms, including Snapchat, TikTok, YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, Reddit, Kick, X, Twitch and Threads. Only YouTube Kids has secured an exemption for a teen-specific version.
Lloyd acknowledged that the ban does affect the ability of under-16s to engage in political communication, but described the impact as narrow, indirect and modest. He added that the restriction applies to account holders regardless of the political content they seek and is “viewpoint neutral,” noting it would be harder to justify if it applied only to supporters of a particular party. Children can still access non-banned services and view content on Reddit and YouTube without an account.
The hearing was scheduled to conclude on Wednesday afternoon.