Critics Call for Withdrawal of Draft Conversion Practices Bill Over Parental Criminalisation Concerns

Résumé

A coalition of MPs, peers, experts and advocacy groups is urging the government to scrap the draft Conversion Practices Bill, warning it could criminalise ordinary parental conversations about gender.

The draft Conversion Practices Bill, published in June, would create offences carrying up to five years’ imprisonment for using physical or psychological pressure to prevent a child from expressing a gay or transgender identity. Critics say the wording is broad enough to encompass routine parental guidance and private family discussions.

"Parents should be able to talk to their children without worrying that an ordinary conversation will land them in court," said Kemi Badenoch, a Conservative minister.

"I fully support the campaign to scrap this bill. Parents should never be criminalised for simply having conversations with their children about their gender," said Nigel Farage, leader of Reform UK.

Baroness Falkner, a former Equality and Human Rights Commission chair, warned that the bill could criminalise attempts to persuade someone that they are not a cat, referencing the emerging "catgender" identity. She urged Labour leader Andy Burnham to abandon the proposal, noting it was a manifesto commitment.

Two former Tavistock clinic whistle-blowers, psychotherapists Sue and Marcus Evans, argued the legislation would deter open family dialogue and could harm siblings and professionals trying to help children with gender dysphoria.

Former Labour MP Rosie Duffield described the bill as "chilling" and said it would make it impossible to police private family relationships, potentially silencing therapists, teachers and grandparents.

Evolutionary biologist Prof Richard Dawkins, speaking for the campaign, said that encouraging children to adopt a gender identity contrary to their biological sex constitutes an "anti-scientific delusion" that should be prosecuted.

Advocacy groups, including Sex Matters and the LGB Alliance, have called for amendments to exclude parents from prosecution and to narrow the definitions of "abuse" and "gender identity". They argue the evidence presented by the government to justify the bill is weak.

The Prime Minister’s office responded that the draft does not target regular parenting and that the measures are intended to protect LGBT+ people from coercion or abuse. A government spokesman added that open, exploratory conversations between young people and adults would remain permissible.

The debate continues as lawmakers consider whether the draft legislation strikes the appropriate balance between preventing genuine conversion-practice abuse and preserving parental rights.

Continuez à lire — gratuitement

Créez un compte gratuit pour suivre l'actualité. Aucune carte requise.