Experts warn AI copyright reforms could breach Australian constitution
Cleared

Experts warn AI copyright reforms could breach Australian constitution

Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.

Summary

Lawmakers and industry groups say proposed changes allowing AI to scrape copyrighted material may violate the constitutional requirement for just terms and could trigger large compensation claims.

The Australian government is considering reforms to copyright law that would permit artificial-intelligence companies to scrape music, books and news content for training purposes. Constitutional scholars and opposition senators warned that such measures could amount to an acquisition of property by the state without "just terms," potentially breaching section 51 of the constitution.

"We could be liable for ‘just terms’ compensation for acquiring that property for every rights holder on Earth," said Nationals senator Ross Cadell during a parliamentary committee hearing. Shadow attorney-general Michaelia Cash added that the government should not "sell out Australian creators and rights holders in the rush to entice AI investment."

Attorney-General Department spokesperson Michelle Rowland said the government is "committed to supporting" creatives and will aim to ensure any copyright changes provide "meaningful control and fair compensation."

University of Sydney law professor Anne Twomey noted that while no specific legislative proposal has been released, granting AI firms a new right to use copyrighted material could raise complex constitutional questions. "One would want to be quite confident before enacting the legislation about whether or not section 51 would apply," she told Guardian Australia.

Industry representatives also expressed concern. Annabelle Herd, CEO of the Australian Recording Industry Association, described the proposed scraping as "clearly an acquisition of property" and warned of potential legal challenges. Chris Maund, CEO of Mushroom Records, argued that existing licensing arrangements should be used and cautioned that weakening copyright law could allow AI companies to train in Australia while bypassing protections elsewhere.

The debate comes as the Labor government prepares a broader AI policy package covering data centres, online safety, workforce, energy and the economy. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has pledged "the strongest possible protection" for creators, describing the use of their work without payment as "theft."

Keep reading — for free

Create a free account to follow the news. No card required.