Auction premiums for home sellers narrow as market slows in Melbourne and Sydney
Data from Ray White shows Melbourne sellers still earn about a 9% premium over pre-auction offers, but the gap has tightened in both Melbourne and Sydney amid a downturn.
Sellers who choose to sell their homes at auction are still achieving higher prices than those who accept the highest pre-auction offer, although the advantage has lessened in recent months, according to Ray White auction data. In Melbourne, the median premium was 8.9% over the highest prior offer, while Sydney saw an 8.1% premium, based on a rolling 13-week median.
Historically, auction premiums in the two cities have peaked at 13.3% in Melbourne (October 2021) and about 11.5% in Sydney (February 2022). The current figures reflect the impact of successive interest-rate hikes, legislative changes and a cost-of-living squeeze on the property market.
"I think that’s important at the moment," Ray White chief economist Nerida Conisbee said. "Because we have quite a significant mismatch between what owners are wanting for their properties and what buyers are prepared to pay."
Conisbee added that the narrowing gap signals reduced competition among bidders, noting that fewer houses are being put up for auction. "When you have less competition, [the] gap narrows," she said, adding that buyers now have more time and face less rivalry.
Sydney-based agent and auctioneer Max Wagschall of Murphy Residential expects the premium to shrink further by year-end, as vendors increasingly view auction as a risky way to test the market. He said many sellers may prefer early offers when they are uncertain about meeting reserve prices.
Clearance rates remain below 60% in both cities, with Sydney at 43% and Melbourne at 54% last week, indicating a balanced market. Nonetheless, Conisbee noted that homes listed for auction are more likely to sell within 45 days, even if they do not sell on auction day, compared with private treaty sales.
"A property that is on market for a long time does tend to lose value," she said, adding that days on market are rising sharply.
Melbourne auctioneer James Pilliner of Nelson Alexander said auctions are best suited to properties that can attract three or four serious bidders within a four-week cycle, typically inner-city homes. For properties unlikely to draw that level of interest, he recommends alternative selling methods.
Independent consultant Jason Lien reported a 90% drop-off in the number of auctions his firm is running, attributing the decline to a lack of bidders despite falling house prices. He suggested that limited demand may push vendors toward early offers, though he believes well-matched properties can still achieve top results at auction.
"The best auctions are usually ones where there’s literally two people who really want it. They become irrational ... it’s not always logical thinking," Lien said.