Supreme Court adjourns hearing on petitions questioning Election Commission's decision-making
दक्षिणपंथी

Supreme Court adjourns hearing on petitions questioning Election Commission's decision-making

सारांश

The Supreme Court gave petitioners ten days to file a rejoinder in cases alleging that the Election Commission of India made several decisions without the consent of all commissioners, and scheduled the next hearing for Nov. 17.

The Supreme Court adjourned a batch of petitions that challenge the functioning of the Election Commission of India (ECI), granting the petitioners ten days to file a rejoinder to the commission’s counter-affidavit. The bench, comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana, is examining allegations that Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and the commission took several decisions, including those related to the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, without the concurrence of the other two Election Commissioners.

Senior Advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi, representing a petition filed by Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi and other INDIA bloc leaders, asked the court to preserve file-notings and internal communications, saying that the issue hinges on whether the decisions were unanimous. "This whole issue depends on the decision-making process, consultation, and whether the decision was unanimous or not unanimous. Let file notings, etc be preserved," Singhvi said. The chief justice responded, "We know everything, we will examine."

Senior Advocate Dr. Menaka Guruswamy, appearing for a writ petition filed by West Bengal MP Dola Sen, argued that the ECI’s affidavit supported the petitioners’ claims and alleged tampering with Form 6, as well as a press release that misrepresented Supreme Court approval. The ECI’s counsel, Dr. Maninder Singh, dismissed the allegation as rhetoric intended for external audiences.

Petitioner Rakesh Singh’s counsel, Senior Advocate Vikas Singh, requested additional time to file a rejoinder. The bench tentatively set the next hearing for November 17.

In the lead case, the court had issued notice on October 5 after declining an ex-parte interim order to suspend CEC Gyanesh Kumar. The ECI’s counter-affidavit asserts that all SIR-related decisions were taken unanimously and that Form 6 was not amended. It also contended that a petition seeking to restrain the CEC from performing his duties is not maintainable under Article 324(5) of the Constitution, which prescribes the same removal procedure for the CEC as for a Supreme Court judge.

The petitions were filed following a report by The Indian Express that claimed at least 14 key SIR decisions were made despite objections from Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi. Apart from Rakesh Singh, petitioners include Rahul Gandhi, other INDIA bloc leaders, the Human Justice Organization, Priya Mishra, AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi, former MP Digvijay Singh, and MP Dola Sen. They question whether the commission’s actions comply with the constitutional framework under Article 324 and the statutory provisions of the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners Act, 2023.

Earlier, Senior Advocate Vikas Singh had urged the court to grant interim relief, warning that the allegations raised serious concerns about the poll body’s functioning and the protection of voting rights. The bench expressed reservations about suspending the CEC without hearing the respondents, noting that such an order could impede the commission’s ability to conduct elections. Chief Justice Kant observed that the law governing the commission’s decision-making process is mandatory and that the court would overturn any action found to violate it. Justice Bagchi questioned whether the court could issue an ex-parte order deeming the disputed decisions unilateral without examining the records and hearing the respondents.

The bench issued notice to the Union government, the ECI, CEC Gyanesh Kumar, Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, Deputy Election Commissioner Maneesh Garg and Director General (IT) Seema Khanna.

स्रोत

Live Law

पढ़ते रहें — निःशुल्क

समाचार फ़ॉलो करने के लिए मुफ़्त खाता बनाएँ। कार्ड की आवश्यकता नहीं।