Philp Warns Labour Not to Gut ILR Reform as Conservatives Offer Backing
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
Chris Philp has urged Shabana Mahmood to keep her tougher ILR plan for migrant care workers, warning that backing down would betray the public and offering Conservative support if she stands firm.
Conservative shadow home secretary Chris Philp sent a letter to Labour Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood insisting that she keep her proposals on indefinite leave to remain (ILR) for migrant care workers and not bow to pressure to weaken them. Philp said the Conservative Party would support her if she refuses to dilute the plan, but warned that if she caves in, her position could become untenable. He cited Home Office research estimating a cost of about £9.5 billion for granting ILR to roughly 117,000 low-paid care workers and their dependents.
Mahmood’s original plan, announced a year ago, would allow migrants employed in specified public-service occupations for five years to reduce the waiting period for ILR by five years. The Home Office is reportedly reviewing options that would factor a migrant’s professional history and sector allegiance into settlement timelines.
Labour ministers Angela Rayner and Miatta Fahnbulleh have raised concerns about the proposals, urging a softer approach. Rayner told Sky News that she trusts Mahmood to develop a system that recognises the contributions of public-service workers while protecting taxpayers.
"You know you can comfortably pass your original plans with our votes in parliament," Philp wrote. "But if you back down to pressure that would cost £10 bn and would be an ‘affront’ to the British public, then I think your position as Home Secretary will become untenable. I hope you instead accept our support to do the right thing."
Philp added that the Labour left, led by Rayner, appears to be steering the policy direction, and suggested that reversing the proposals could damage Mahmood’s credibility.
The debate reflects ongoing tensions within the UK government over how to balance immigration policy, public-service staffing needs, and fiscal considerations.