Alexander brothers face sentencing for federal sex-trafficking convictions
Tal, Alon and Oren Alexander were convicted on multiple sex-trafficking charges and are scheduled to be sentenced Tuesday in Manhattan federal court.
A Manhattan federal judge will sentence three brothers—Tal, Alon and Oren Alexander—on Tuesday after a jury found them guilty of sex trafficking, conspiracy to commit sex trafficking and related offenses. Prosecutors say the brothers used their wealth and social connections to lure women and girls to parties, vacations and other locations, where they were allegedly drugged, assaulted and, in some cases, forced to travel for illegal sexual activity. The convictions cover incidents from 2008 to 2021, with prosecutors asserting the pattern began in the early 2000s.
More than 70 women reportedly came forward during the investigation, and 11 testified at the five-week trial. Evidence presented included video and photographic material recovered from the brothers’ devices. One victim, who was 17 at the time of an alleged assault by Oren Alexander, said she learned of the rape only after investigators identified her in a 2009 recording.
The government’s sentencing memorandum recommends life imprisonment, citing enhancements for victims who were minors, drugged or unconscious, and for the use of force. > "They were not party boys, playboys, womanizers, or misguided young men. They were predators. They spent years hunting and preying upon women because they wanted to, because they could, and because they kept getting away with it," the memo states.
Defense attorneys argue for a 15-year sentence, the minimum for a single count of sex trafficking, and contend that the conduct does not fit the statutory definition of sex trafficking. They also emphasize the brothers’ recent marriages, children and letters from acquaintances describing them as supportive family members. > "It was charged as a sex trafficking case and it was tried as a federal rape case," Oren Alexander’s lawyer Marc Agnifilo said at a recent hearing.
Judge Valerie Caproni indicated she will consider whether the brothers should be housed together, noting her concern that they could influence each other negatively. Victims are expected to address the court during sentencing, and the brothers plan to speak as well. The twins also face two pending rape cases in Florida state court and multiple civil lawsuits from accusers.