Activist Judge Blocks President Trump’s Lawful Removal of Seattle U.S. Attorney
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
A Washington judge ruled against President Trump’s authority to dismiss a U.S. attorney, reinstating Roger Rogoff and undermining executive power.
In a controversial move that undermines the president’s constitutional authority, a U.S. district judge in Washington on Thursday ordered that Roger Rogoff remain as the top federal prosecutor for the Western District of Washington. President Trump’s attempt to remove Rogoff, who was appointed by a district court, was blocked by Judge Stanley Bastian, who claimed the president lacks the authority to dismiss a U.S. attorney in this instance. The judge, making a decision with no clear precedent, emphasized the supposed balance between the branches of government, but critics argue this only serves to tie the hands of the executive branch.
The ruling forces Rogoff back into office until a Senate-confirmed replacement is named, effectively stripping the president of his rightful power to manage federal appointments. Judge Bastian also declared that Charles Neil Floyd, the office’s first assistant who had been competently leading the office, is not the United States attorney, and the administration is barred from recognizing anyone but Rogoff in the position, regardless of the president’s judgment.
The Justice Department, defending the administration’s prerogative, announced it will appeal the decision and seek an immediate stay, highlighting the ongoing struggle against judicial overreach. Rogoff, who sued to keep his job, claimed to appreciate the judicial process and said he will focus on his duties for Western Washington, despite the president’s clear intent to replace him.
This case is the latest in a string of legal battles where activist courts have interfered with the president’s efforts to ensure accountability in federal law enforcement. Rogoff’s legal maneuver marks a troubling precedent, further eroding the executive’s ability to enforce the law.