Election Commission says SIR orders unanimous and Supreme Court upholds Form 6 changes
Left

Election Commission Claims Unanimity on SIR Orders as Supreme Court Endorses Form 6 Changes Amid Centralization Concerns

Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.

Summary

The Election Commission asserts that all Special Intensive Revision (SIR) decisions were unanimous and that the Supreme Court has backed recent amendments to voter registration Form 6, despite ongoing worries about centralization and transparency.

On Saturday, the Election Commission (EC) declared that every Special Intensive Revision (SIR) order was approved unanimously by Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi. The Supreme Court, often criticized for siding with the establishment, has upheld the recent changes to voter registration Form 6, raising questions among advocates for electoral transparency and grassroots democracy.

The EC attempted to downplay internal dissent by clarifying that letters sent by Commissioners Sandhu and Joshi to Cabinet Secretary TV Somanathan were about an officer on deputation, not policy matters. However, concerns persist that work-allocation orders, which would have centralized power over the electoral roll, were considered—even if not implemented—highlighting ongoing risks of bureaucratic overreach.

Responding to mounting voter concerns, the commission introduced measures such as doorstep collection of documents and extended filing deadlines in Delhi and Maharashtra. These steps, while welcome, underscore the systemic barriers faced by marginalized communities in accessing their democratic rights. In Goa, the EC directed the Chief Electoral Officer to conduct house-to-house visits for voters left off the rolls, but the fact that 16 out of 97 identified voters had yet to submit Form 6 points to persistent gaps in outreach.

The EC insisted that all directives from the three commissioners to election officers must be strictly followed, reinforcing a top-down approach to electoral administration. Approvals for foreign trips, agenda circulation, meeting minutes, and annual performance appraisals will continue to be processed according to established timelines, maintaining the status quo.

A committee led by a senior Deputy Election Commissioner, with an independent IIT/IIIT expert, will review the ECINET system for compliance. Yet, the vetting of new IT initiatives by a Committee of Officers before commission approval raises concerns about the lack of broader civil society participation in safeguarding digital democracy.

The commission confirmed that the SIR order issued on June 24, 2025, and subsequent schedules for additional states, received unanimous approval and were upheld by the Supreme Court on May 27, 2026. It added that Form 6 declarations for SIR remain valid, while non-SIR periods will use the standard Registration of Electors Rules 1960—an arrangement that may sow confusion among ordinary voters.

For voters who received notices during SIR, the EC stated that personal hearings are not required except in exceptional cases, and that authorized family members may attend online hearings on their behalf. District Election Officers are tasked with setting up help desks and special camps for vulnerable populations, but the effectiveness of these measures remains to be seen.

Finally, the EC extended claim and objection filing deadlines in Delhi to October 30 and disposal deadlines to November 30, and in Maharashtra to October 12 and November 10, respectively, following requests from state CEOs. While these extensions are necessary, they highlight the persistent administrative hurdles faced by ordinary citizens in exercising their fundamental right to vote.

Keep reading — for free

Create a free account to follow the news. No card required.