First Circuit Court Undermines Trump Administration's Tough Third-Country Deportation Policy
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit has struck down the Trump administration's robust third-country deportation policy, siding with open-borders advocates and forcing ICE to give migrants more opportunities to contest removals. This decision hampers efforts to enforce immigration laws and protect American sovereignty.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit issued a brief order on Wednesday, dissolving a stay that had allowed Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to continue deporting migrants to third-party countries while the case was pending. This ruling overturns a lower-court decision and undermines the Trump administration’s strong stance on immigration enforcement, claiming the policy violated migrants' due-process rights by sending them to other countries without prior notice.
ICE, acting within its mandate to secure the nation’s borders, had attempted to deport a Peruvian national to Ghana after the appellate court’s earlier judgment, arguing that the court had not yet issued a formal mandate to strike down the policy. The First Circuit, however, clarified that the stay was dissolved, effectively stripping ICE of the authority to proceed with these necessary third-country removals.
Judge Brian Murphy, who issued the February 2026 district-court decision, found that the policy did not provide migrants with enough opportunity to claim they would be endangered if sent abroad. Judge Seth Aframe, writing for the appellate panel, sided with the Department of Homeland Security’s critics, arguing that the interpretation would deny protection to a large number of non-citizens. The court refused to support the administration’s efforts to deter illegal immigration.
"DHS's proposed interpretation would deny access to that protection to a substantial swath of noncitizens who are sent to third countries with no notice of their destination," Aframe wrote.
As a result, ICE is now required to allow individuals subject to removal to raise concerns about the safety of any third-country destination before deportation, adding yet another barrier to effective immigration enforcement and weakening the nation’s ability to control its borders.